October 25, 2007 12:21 PM PDT

Who else has stopped caring about the Blu-ray/HD DVD war?

Blu-ray

The Blu-ray winner

(Credit: CNET Networks)

Am I the only person who couldn't care any less about the HD DVD/Blu-ray war? For a while, I was captivated by the prospect of a Sony format winning the format war or the possibility of another Betamax debacle. At one point, I actually cared who won the format war and told everyone which format I believed would win.

But with Wednesday's news that cited figures showing Sony's Blu-ray format had outsold HD DVD by almost 2-to-1, I finally had enough.

Let's be honest with ourselves: at this point, who really cares which format is outselling the other? After each report of higher sales, the backers of the opposing format come out and proclaim their own dominance due to factors a and b. Once that's complete, the winning victor (in this case, Blu-ray) comes out and cites those sales figures just one more time.

Suffice it to say, I'm just plain tired of this war.

As everyone is too well aware, this high-def format war will go on for at least another two years. Regardless of where you stand, movie studios will continue to support whichever format they believe will bring in the most money without actually standing firm on one format or another.

In fact, I believe this market has become the most fickle we have seen in years. Next to the Internet, where people stop visiting Web sites at the drop of a hat, movie studios are quick to jump on either format's bandwagon as long as it can bring in acceptable revenue. Of course, if that much thought was given to high-quality movies, we would actually spend some time in the movie theater and these companies wouldn't need to worry about media. But alas, that's an argument for another day.

Over the past year, we have been inundated with news that purports the ascension of Blu-ray and the demise of HD DVD. And then, when Paramount threw its weight behind the HD DVD folks, that format was heralded as the successor to the DVD. And now, we have news that Blu-ray has outsold HD DVD.

When will it ever end?

HD DVD

The HD DVD winner

(Credit: CNET Networks)

Allow me to just say it: worrying about the high-def format war is a waste of time. And to be quite honest, I don't see these formats being around much longer anyway--movie downloads will quickly supplant media as the chosen form of entertainment once our Internet access speeds increase.

But until then, we're left with nonsensical developments that so far have maintained the standstill and forced people like me to write about who will be the victor.

Well, I for one, will not have that discussion any longer. In fact, I will not discuss both Blu-ray and HD DVD in a piece, nor will I discuss who will win this war. If you want that, give both camps a call. I'm sure they will tell you everything you need to know.

I've succumbed to High-Def Format War Fatigue, and to be quite honest, I think most of the world has too. Eventually, one format will win and the other will lose. In the meantime, ignore the predictions and hyperbole, and get down to enjoying some movies.

Recent posts from The Digital Home
The Digital Home Video: Hulu's success surprised me
The Digital Home 30: Can I stream my wedding?
Developer consolidation is bad for the video game industry
The Digital Home Video: How will we determine TV ratings in the future?
Nintendo shouldn't rush to release the Wii 2
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 8 comments
Both, or None
by john55440 October 25, 2007 12:41 PM PDT
I'm ordering a new HP desktop computer, and haven't decided if I should get a dual Blu-ray / HD DVD reader, or if I shouldn't bother with either format.

A pox on both their houses. :-)
Reply to this comment
My DVD player looks more satisfying to me as ever!
by tekwiz4u October 25, 2007 12:54 PM PDT
I dont really care about seeing more details in movies, like more defined wrinkles in a person's face, or seeing more 'wear and tear' on items and people. As long as you have a good DVD player, you'll probably wont even care about it. Hi-Def movies are a great concept, but it seems like they are having a HUGE pissing contest, and we're getting wet in the process.

I'm not going to buy an expensive piece of equipment only for it to be obsolete in a few months. So LONG LIVE the DVD format, because it certainly looks like its going to be driven that way if this keeps going on.
Reply to this comment
Look at the mess you've gotten me into!
by Fernyyy October 25, 2007 12:56 PM PDT
Last time I checked, my DVD collection looked better on screen (65" projection) than any movie I've ever seen at the theatre. And it costs one heck of a lot less to buy a brand new DVD, watch it once and pitch it than to go to the theatre.

Blu-ray/HD DVD/LMNOP-XYZ... WHO CARES! If I buy another disc player it will play all or just DVD. Like most people who have a pulse, I have larger issues to deal with in my life.
Reply to this comment
I agree, the war is pointless
by sviolette1 October 25, 2007 1:17 PM PDT
I have been debating for months on which to buy and have so far held off which now I am happy about- Downloading movies in HD will eventually replace DVD anyway and it is not that far away. Xbox360 already does some and Vudu (not HD yet) as well as Tivo/amazon unboxed (not HD yet) are hitting the market now. I think it will only be a few years before HD movie downloading is the clear winner, until then I can watch movies on HBO HD.
Reply to this comment
Yes, you are the only person...
by someuser93 October 25, 2007 1:20 PM PDT
"Am I the only person who couldn't care any less about the HD DVD/Blu-ray war?"

Yes, you are. You are the only person who is not on the edge of their seat waiting for the next bit of news. The swarm of other journalists downplaying both formats is just a figment of your imagination.

Thank you, CNET, for this insightful piece of journalism.
</sarcasm>
Reply to this comment
I don't care, but i picked one yesterday!
by usualsuspect87 October 25, 2007 1:32 PM PDT
190 bucks including tax just got me:

HD DVD Player kit for 360 ($180)
King Kong (comes in box with player (maybe $25))
Two HD Movies 34.99 and under (I got Transformers and 300 ($65)
Heroes Season 1 ($100)

All items above i walked out with in my hands, plus you get 5 more free via a mail in rebate form (some will be crap, but there are a few good ones to pick from including full metal jacket (say 25 each, $125)

Total Value of $525 including tax.... You probably couldn?t buy all of these in DVD format for this price...

sure, it'd be nice if they keep making HD Dvd's, but at prices like this, i don't really care if they do or not... if i can squeeze a couple more good flicks it was well worth it...
Reply to this comment
no way I'm buying either until one wins
by Zen-Masta October 25, 2007 1:56 PM PDT
I haven't cared from the start. As I see it, this format war is just as retarded as dvd audio and super audio cd. My other reasons for not caring... selection is horrible, price is too high, I think dvd's still look pretty decent (better then tv as long as they're 6x9), hardware still too expensive.
Reply to this comment
PR is getting old. Economics will win the war.
by neal page November 1, 2007 9:28 PM PDT
Yes, we?re all weary of this format war for HD packaged media. Keep in mind, its still a PR game, one that ultimately will not be won by PR but by economics for the CONSUMER. I blogged about this topic back in June (http://www.inlethd.com/blog/?p=15), specifically on how the format war is hurting the consumer. Recent articles may be signaling the beginning of the end of this frustrating fray. Today I read on CNET that HD DVD breaks the $99 mark! http://www.news.com/8301-10784_3-9809165-7.html. That my friends, is the magic price threshold that sells product in volumes. Now increase the titles, and I?d say the end of the battle is in sight.
Reply to this comment
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement

About The Digital Home

Don Reisinger is a technology columnist who has covered everything from HDTVs to computers to Flowbee Haircut Systems. Besides his work with CNET, Don's work has been featured in a variety of other publications including PC World and a host of Ziff-Davis publications.

Don writes product reviews for InformationWeek and is a regular contributor to Processor Magazine. You can visit his personal site at DonReisinger.com or if you would like to email Don with questions or comments, drop him a line at CNETDigitalHome@gmail.com. He is a member of the CNET Blog Network and is not an employee of CNET. Disclosure.

Add this feed to your online news reader

The Digital Home topics

Subscribe to the Digital Home podcast

Have you ever wanted a no-nonsense discussion on what is really going with all the tech topics related to your Digital Home? If so, join Don Reisinger as he brings you the same biting commentary you've come to expect from his Digital Home blog in all its audio glory.

Subscribe to this podcast using an RSS reader other than iTunes

Subscribe to this podcast using iTunes

Don's links
Don's Facebook account
Don's Twitter feed
Don's Friendfeed account
Don's Google Reader account
Don's Last.FM account
Don's Pownce account
Don's Flickr account

Latest tech news headlines

Featured blogs

advertisement
advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right